Pic-A-Lilli Inn
(609) 268-2066 Order Online
Order Online (609) 268-2066

866 US-206, Shamong, NJ 08088

The Full Spread

The Menu

Everything we make, with prices — no PDFs, no guessing. Order any of it online, or come pull up a stool.

Order Online Jump to wings

Full menu and prices as of 2026, from the Pic-A-Lilli kitchen. Prices subject to change. Choose your wing sauce at checkout. 20% gratuity added to parties of 6 or more. All credit cards subject to a 3% processing fee.

Housemade Soups

  • Creamy Crab Soup Favorite

    $9

  • Loaded Baked Potato

    $9

  • Crock of French Onion

    $8

  • Chef Phil's Homemade Chili

    $9

Shareables

Shareables

  • Fried Pickles

    $9

  • Mozzarella Sticks

    $9

  • Broccoli Cheddar Bites

    $10

  • Spicy Fried Green Beans

    $10

  • Cheese Curds

    $9

  • Mexican Street Corn Nuggets

    Corn fritters drizzled with street corn dressing, cotija cheese & Tajín.

    $11

  • Pic Fries Favorite

    House-made white cheese, lump crabmeat, scallions & Old Bay.

    $12

  • Big Bavarian Pretzel

    Colossal pretzel, house-made cheese sauce, spicy mustard & cinna-dip.

    $12

Salads

All salads start with romaine. Add a protein: chicken +$6 / shrimp +market price. Dressings: balsamic vinaigrette, bleu cheese, Caesar, French, honey mustard, ranch, Russian.

Salads

  • House

    Tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions & croutons.

    $9

  • Pic's Cobb

    Tomatoes, bacon, hard-boiled egg, cheddar cheese.

    $14

  • Caesar

    Parmesan, croutons, Caesar dressing.

    $14

  • Buffalo Chicken Salad Favorite

    Buffalo ears, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onion, crumbled bleu cheese, croutons & bleu cheese dressing.

    $20

Shellfish

  • Garlic Steamed Clams (12)

    $18

  • Clams on the ½ Shell (12)

    $16

  • Clams Casino (6)

    $14

  • Oysters Casino (6)

    Our famous Casino recipe on top of an oyster.

    $16

  • Oysters

    Sweetwater Oyster Co., Barnegat Bay, NJ.

    (6) $10 · (12) $20

  • Crab Bread

    $16

  • Bang Bang Shrimp (½ lb)

    Market price

Buffalo — The Originals

Choose your sauce at checkout: Mild, Spicy, Hot, Smoker, Garlic Parm, Bang Bang, Honey BBQ or Hot & Honey.

Buffalo — The Originals

  • Our Famous Wings Favorite

    (6) $9 · (13) $15 · (25) $27 · (50) $45 · (100) $80

  • Ears Favorite

    Breaded chicken cutlets.

    (4) $12 · (8) $23 · (20) $40 · (50) $80

  • Tails Favorite

    Fresh chicken breast.

    (4) $12 · (8) $23 · (20) $40 · (50) $80

  • Wings, Tails & Ears Combos

    (4,4,4) $25 · (8,8,8) $50

  • Buffalo Shrimp

    ½ lb, ¾ lb or 1 lb.

    Market price

Baskets

Includes fries, blue cheese & celery.

Baskets

  • Wing Basket

    (6) $14 · (13) $18

  • Tail Basket

    (4) $17 · (8) $27

  • Ear Basket

    (4) $17 · (8) $27

  • Chicken Fingers

    Fries, honey mustard or BBQ sauce.

    (2) $8 · (4) $17 · (8) $27

Buffalo Specials

  • Buffalo Chik'n Sandwich

    Ears, bleu cheese. Regular or vegan.

    $14

  • Buffalo Chicken Roll

    Hand-rolled (2).

    $12

Buffalo Extras

  • Bleu Cheese or Ranch

    $1.50

  • Small Celery

    $3

Between the Bread

All sandwiches served with fries. Choose beef, turkey or black bean.

  • Classic Cheeseburger

    $15

  • Cowboy Burger

    Cheddar cheese, bacon, BBQ sauce, onion ring.

    $16

  • Smash Burger Favorite

    Double burger of Angus beef, cheddar cheese & onions.

    $16

  • Reuben Burger

    Angus beef, locally sourced corned beef, Swiss cheese, cole slaw, Russian dressing, brioche bun.

    $16

  • Venison Smash Burger

    Venison patties, maple-glazed cranberry onions, creamy brie, bacon, brioche bun.

    $22

  • Back Porch Bird

    Pickle-brined, hand-breaded chicken cutlet, fontina cheese, lettuce, pickles & spicy ranch, brioche bun. Served with fries.

    $17

  • Grilled Russian Turkey

    Turkey, Swiss, cole slaw, Russian dressing, grilled rye.

    $16

  • Pulled Pork

    Sweet potato fries, coleslaw, brioche bun.

    $18

  • Prime Rib Dip

    Sautéed onions, provolone cheese, horseradish, au jus.

    $20

  • Portobello Swiss

    House-marinated portobello mushroom, Swiss.

    $13

  • Crispy Chicken BLT

    Crispy chicken, fontina, bacon, lettuce, sundried-tomato mayo, ciabatta bun.

    $16

  • Shrimp Po Boy

    Fried shrimp, lettuce, bang bang sauce.

    $18

Cheesesteaks

All steaks made with Cooper American. Gluten-free bun available.

Cheesesteaks

  • Cheesesteak Favorite

    Local shaved ribeye, Cooper American.

    $17

  • Chicken Cheesesteak

    $16

  • Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak

    American, choice of wing sauce.

    $17

Entrées

Entrées

  • Hand Made Chicken Pot Pie Favorite

    Hand-pulled chicken, creamy vegetable filling, pastry crust.

    $20

  • Fish & Chips

    Yuengling-battered cod, malt vinegar, cole slaw, lemon.

    $18

  • BBQ Platter

    Pulled pork, ½ rack, mac 'n cheese, slaw, corn muffin.

    $30

  • Prime Rib

    16 oz prime rib, broccoli, baked potato, horseradish, au jus.

    $35

Sides

  • French Fries

    Add Old Bay $1.

    $6

  • Curly Fries

    $8

  • Sweet Potato Fries

    House-made maple dip.

    $8

  • Onion Rings

    $10

  • Garlic Bread

    $4

  • Coleslaw

    $4

  • Baked Potato

    $4

  • Loaded Baked Potato

    Cheese, bacon, sour cream.

    $6

Kids

  • Chicken Fingers (2) & Fries

    $8

  • Hot Dog Sliders (2) & Fries

    $6

  • Grilled Cheese & Fries

    $7

  • Mac & Cheese

    $6

  • Pasta

    Butter or marinara sauce.

    $5

Drinks

  • Pepsi Products

    Pepsi, Pepsi Zero, Starry, Mt. Dew, Brisk Raspberry Tea, Orange Crush, lemonade.

    $4

  • Birch Beer on Tap

    No free refills.

    $5

  • Coffee or Hot Tea

    $3

  • Freshly Brewed Iced Tea

    $3

  • Milk

    $4

  • Chocolate Milk

    $4

Hungry yet?

Order online for pickup, or call and we'll get you sorted.

Order Online (609) 268-2066
Call Order Online